What's New
Off Topix: Embrace the Unexpected in Every Discussion

Off Topix is a well established general discussion forum that originally opened to the public way back in 2009! We provide a laid back atmosphere and our members are down to earth. We have a ton of content and fresh stuff is constantly being added. We cover all sorts of topics, so there's bound to be something inside to pique your interest. We welcome anyone and everyone to register & become a member of our awesome community.

No same-sex wedding cakes

Jazzy

Wild Thing
Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2010
Posts
79,918
OT Bucks
308,876
DENVER - The owner of a bakery in Lakewood said he will no longer sell wedding cakes after the Colorado Civil Rights Commission ruled he did discriminate against a gay couple when he refused to sell them a cake.

Jack Phillips owns Masterpiece Cakeshop. In 2012, David Mullins and Charlie Craig went to the shop to order a cake for their upcoming wedding reception. They planned to marry in Massachusetts and have a reception in Colorado.

Phillips said he doesn't believe in gay marriage and he refused to sell them a cake.

"We would close down the bakery before we would complicate our beliefs," Phillips said after the hearing, according to CBS Denver. Phillips also admitted he had refused service to other same-sex couples.

A judge previously ruled a business owner cannot refuse service to a customer on the basis of sexual orientation. Phillips appealed to the commission, but it upheld the decision.

That prompted Phillips to decide he would no longer make any wedding cakes. He said he would be fine selling cupcakes for a birthday party for someone who is gay but added, "I don't want to participate in a same-sex wedding."

The commission also ordered the baker to submit quarterly reports about the customers he refuses to serve and retrain employees to serve everyone.

Source

Do you think this owner has a right to refuse to make same-sex wedding cakes? Why / Why not?
 
It's a private business. He can refuse service to anyone.

But, of course, now it is a crime to refuse to do handsprings when in the presence of homosexuals.

When the law passed here, my wife said if she were asked to photograph a gay wedding, she would tell them she doesn't do weddings any more.
 
Sure he has a right to refuse, it's his work and if he feels he's participating in something he feels in his soul isn't right, then he shouldn't be made to sell anything.
 
Seems immature and childish to refuse service to a gay customer. Its not like selling a cake will turn him gay or compromise his beliefs. Business is business and he should appreciate any customer willing to spend money at his shop.
 
They planned to marry in Massachusetts and have a reception in Colorado.
"I don't want to participate in a same-sex wedding."

Hmm, these men weren't even getting married in his state. So, how could he have participated in their wedding? :s

On another note: It might be a private business but it's open to the public. Would have been different if he was making wedding cakes in his home and selling them privately. As mentioned by Nebulous, did he think selling them a cake would turn him gay? :lol:

Hope this bakery owner doesn't have any children. Can you imagine his son or daughter going to him one day and saying: "Hey Dad, I need to tell you something.......I'm gay."
 
Whatever you, they, somebody else, wants to do in the privacy of their own home is their business.

If I don't want to be part of it at any level, am I now required to become involved otherwise I am branded as "Intolerant"?

Why do I have to tolerate them, and they are not expected to return the favor?
 
Sure, he has the right.
I would consider it bad business, though. If I were a baker, I'd damn well make cake for every paying customer. Kim Jong-un wants to buy my cake? Perfect, more money for me.
DrLeftover said:
If I don't want to be part of it at any level, am I now required to become involved otherwise I am branded as "Intolerant"?
You know the answer.

I'm sure you can imagine how hard it would be to be truly non-involved. Being involved you will be branded in much the same way Democrats, Republicans, and Independents brand one another.
 
I wonder if this baker refuses service to people who have different religions as well?

...Should he have his customers fill out a questionnaire to make sure all their beliefs match up to his before he makes them a cake? :lol:
 
Why the hell does it matter what other peoples sexual preferences are? Does that impact his life directly? I never understood why this was becoming a governmental issue. Gay Rights? Really, we need to address something like that?

So if I do not like the color red (I love the color red, this is just an example), does that mean I can refuse anyone that wears red, or likes the color red? Then liking that color does not impact my life, but I have the right to refuse that customer? That is so lame and immorally wrong...
 
Up to him, I suppose.
But it's a shame for the gay couple at the same time. He's entitled to his own biases, I suppose.
 
Back
Top Bottom