Harry Potter Vs Twilight

Flurry

Crisis Management

Member

Joined

Nov 22, 2009

Posts

15,344

OT Bucks

29,876

• Jul 27, 2010

• #21

Cranos said:

Harry Potter, it's well written and it has a nice story. Granted, the films suck, but Twilight is a seriously fucked up story and those films are even worse. I don't get how it could get this popular anyway, the writing is terrible.

Click to expand...

That, and when you think about it. Its kind of promoting Necrophilia. And Harry Potter for the win!

 

beowulf

Cat Slave

Member

Joined

May 30, 2010

Posts

2,779

OT Bucks

6,064

• Jul 27, 2010

• #22

harry potter definatly...........seen most of them and enjoyed them



seen bits of twilight and it just does not appeal....vampires should be like Blade not sparkling!

 

oscarg

Off Topix Regular

Member

Joined

Jul 27, 2010

Posts

65

OT Bucks

199

• Jul 31, 2010

• #23

Twilight!

 

N!ck

Dedicated Member

Member

Joined

Jul 24, 2010

Posts

222

OT Bucks

553

• Aug 1, 2010

• #24

Harry Potter = Normal Wizards

Twilight = wtf glittery vampires and a boy who can grow pubic hair all over his body in a full moon? no thanks

 

Fayble

Formerly known as Karrit

Member

Joined

Jan 27, 2010

Posts

303

OT Bucks

1,131

• Aug 1, 2010

• #25

Harry Potter for sure!

 

manojob

Dedicated Member

Member

Joined

Oct 1, 2012

Posts

204

OT Bucks

363

• Oct 23, 2012

• #26

I prefer to see Harry Potter.

 

Crys

Mic Drop.

Elite Member

Joined

May 21, 2023

Posts

1,858

OT Bucks

3,646

• Dec 3, 2023

• #27

The Sound of Music.

 

MamaFrankie

The Guv'nor's Other Woman (Lord Julian's Consort)

Member

Joined

Jul 3, 2022

Posts

1,770

OT Bucks

3,713

• May 15, 2025

• #28

Harry Potter for 2 reasons:

1) I like Harry Potter.
2) I can't stand Robert Pattinson.

 

duskpire

Night Owl

Administrator

Joined

Dec 26, 2014

Posts

23,018

OT Bucks

1,698

• May 15, 2025

• #29

MamaFrankie said:

2) I can't stand Robert Pattinson.

Click to expand...

 

MamaFrankie

The Guv'nor's Other Woman (Lord Julian's Consort)

Member

Joined

Jul 3, 2022

Posts

1,770

OT Bucks

3,713

• May 15, 2025

• #30

He's an arrogant asshat.

 

Cam

Cam'tn Crunch

Cam'tn Crunch

Administrator

Joined

Aug 12, 2010

Posts

1,619

OT Bucks

1,289

• May 15, 2025

• #31

These two book/movie series really aren't comparable. Harry Potter will be celebrated hundreds of years from now. Don't see that happening with Twilight.

 

Dead2009

Horror Movie Guru

Moderator

Joined

Mar 8, 2024

Posts

2,881

OT Bucks

8,624

• May 17, 2025

• #32

If I HAD to choose, it would be Harry Potter.

 

Hulk

Platinum Member

Elite Member

Joined

Nov 15, 2010

Posts

9,826

OT Bucks

694

• May 17, 2025

• #33

Both have amazing casts but Alan Rickman isn't in Twilight so mine is Harry Potter.

 

Kyng

Gold Member

Elite Member

Joined

Oct 11, 2014

Posts

2,352

OT Bucks

3,073

• May 29, 2025

• #34

Harry Potter... I've been a fan for 20+ years now!

 

duskpire

Night Owl

Administrator

Joined

Dec 26, 2014

Posts

23,018

OT Bucks

1,698

• May 29, 2025

• #35

MamaFrankie said:

He's an arrogant asshat.

Click to expand...

I just never thought he was a good actor.

 

KO896

Gold Member

MOTM

Joined

May 31, 2020

Posts

2,082

OT Bucks

1,630

• May 30, 2025

• #36

I choose Harry Potter! I read both of the books, but Harry Potter is much more organized in the various plots/subplots.

 

MamaFrankie

The Guv'nor's Other Woman (Lord Julian's Consort)

Member

Joined

Jul 3, 2022

Posts

1,770

OT Bucks

3,713

• May 30, 2025

• #37

I've even created a universe and character inspired by Harry and am currently writing a book about it. It is a spoof autobiography of my fictional Great Uncle Manfred.

 

Webster

Retired Snark Master

Administrator

Joined

May 11, 2013

Posts

25,807

OT Bucks

70,903

• May 30, 2025

• #38

MamaFrankie said:

I can't stand Robert Pattinson

Click to expand...

His portrayal of Edward Cullen might be a role he'll never be able to escape (I say that given his later performance in 2022's The Batman as the masked crusader).

That said, I'm not really fond of either (Twilight 'cause of its' portrayal of both vampires/werewolves, Potter 'cause of my antipathy towards JK Rowling w/regards to trans people).

 

Dee

Platinum Member

Elite Member

Joined

Jun 23, 2014

Posts

5,584

OT Bucks

5,773

• Jun 5, 2025

• #39

I find it hilarious that Twilight has no votes. In any case, I voted Harry Potter. If it were the MST3K version, then Twilight.