What's New
Off Topix: Embrace the Unexpected in Every Discussion

Off Topix is a well established general discussion forum that originally opened to the public way back in 2009! We provide a laid back atmosphere and our members are down to earth. We have a ton of content and fresh stuff is constantly being added. We cover all sorts of topics, so there's bound to be something inside to pique your interest. We welcome anyone and everyone to register & become a member of our awesome community.

Bulimia by Nicholas McConnaughay

McConnaughay

An Instant Classic
Elite Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2010
Posts
4,837
OT Bucks
12,820
Rating: PG13
Word Count: 420
Feedback: I'd like an opinion on the story as a whole, as well as citing over any of the specific grammatical errors that might be in there.
Author's Comments: This is one of the first short-stories that I ever wrote, however, I liked it for some reason. I think it's more to say that I really liked the punch-line. At the time, I was going through a lot of anger and bitterness, I suppose that this was one of my ways of letting it out. I wrote this story about the same time that I wrote my first novel, in so, the story was written somewhere around two or three years ago. I decided to post it up because I am starting a website soon that will feature a lot of my short-stories, and I wanted to clean them up before posting them.



---​


I was there, but she never knew. I was there, that much is true.

Of course, she didn't know that I was watching. It put a strain on our relationship because I knew more about her then even she knew about herself, but she had never batted as much as an eye in my direction. I saw her. I saw her the way that everyone else saw her. She was beautiful, but she never chose to see it that way when she looked in the mirror.

She saw the ugly that wasn't there. She somehow saw filfth inside her hair.

She was beautiful. Her face could have lit up an entire city with ease. Her body, not curved like a baseball thrown in the big-leagues, was perfect to me. She didn't see it that way and often times, she'd stop dead in her tracks to gaze at the abomenation looking back at her in the mirror. She didn't see the kindless of her smile because she was never smiling, not when she looked into that damn mirror!

She saw the sparkle in her eyes only when at the brink of tears. When she looked in the mirror, she saw the vomit hitting the ground and missing the toilet bowl, and all her past rejections. She looked in the mirror and she saw everything that she hadn't gotten in life, and she wondered why. She wondered why nobody asked her to prom, and she wondered why everybody told her and told her that she was skinny.

Their comfort fell upon deaf-ears. In that mirror was all her fears.

In that mirror, she put all of her pain, and what came out was something that wasn't there. She saw something that everybody else was entirely oblivious to; she saw something so ugly and flawed.

I wish I could have told her other-wise, and put ease to her conscious and vapid cries.

The images projecting themselves in-front of her weren't really there. I didn't, I couldn't, so instead, I stared.

I watched as she broke the mirror, and then a shard met her wrist.

There was nothing that could scathe her more than this monstrous shell, her decrepit exterior. All that she seemed to care about was making it all fade away, and she did it.

I wished I could have been given the opportunity to save her, but to her, on the top of this tree branch, I had merely the mind of a squirrel.
 
All right, I wasn't expecting that. Well done.
Nebulous said:
Aww, true story?
He's secretly a squirrel :P
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
filfth [...] abomenation [...] kindless
I suggest you do some spell checking before launching your website :tup:
 
Evil Eye said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
filfth [...] abomenation [...] kindless
I suggest you do some spell checking before launching your website :tup:

You do realize the entire point that I am releasing these on forums before putting them on the website is because I want to polish it up, right? I am looking for criticism, not snark, fart-face!
 
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
Evil Eye said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
filfth [...] abomenation [...] kindless
I suggest you do some spell checking before launching your website :tup:

You do realize the entire point that I am releasing these on forums before putting them on the website is because I want to polish it up, right? I am looking for criticism, not snark, fart-face!

He was helping you.... :unsure:
 
Nebulous said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
Evil Eye said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
filfth [...] abomenation [...] kindless
I suggest you do some spell checking before launching your website :tup:

You do realize the entire point that I am releasing these on forums before putting them on the website is because I want to polish it up, right? I am looking for criticism, not snark, fart-face!

He was helping you.... :unsure:

With an added sass, which I responded to my referring to him as a fart-face. Light-heart snark responded to by light-heart insult. A fair exchange. :yes:
 
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
Nebulous said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
Evil Eye said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
filfth [...] abomenation [...] kindless
I suggest you do some spell checking before launching your website :tup:

You do realize the entire point that I am releasing these on forums before putting them on the website is because I want to polish it up, right? I am looking for criticism, not snark, fart-face!

He was helping you.... :unsure:

True, but with an added sass, which I responded to my referring to him as a fart-face. :yes:

The :tup: face is not sass. :tup:
 
Nebulous said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
Nebulous said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
Evil Eye said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
filfth [...] abomenation [...] kindless
I suggest you do some spell checking before launching your website :tup:

You do realize the entire point that I am releasing these on forums before putting them on the website is because I want to polish it up, right? I am looking for criticism, not snark, fart-face!

He was helping you.... :unsure:

True, but with an added sass, which I responded to my referring to him as a fart-face. :yes:

The :tup: face is not sass. :tup:
I didn't mean it seriously. Hence why I called him a fart-face and not something more wholesome. The sass was him saying I needed to use spell-check, which was I took as very sassy. (In a sexy sort-of way.)

(Although, Fun-Fact: When I first rewrote it, it was on a forum called Legendfire that doesn't allow spell-check.)
 
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
Nebulous said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
Nebulous said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
Evil Eye said:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
filfth [...] abomenation [...] kindless
I suggest you do some spell checking before launching your website :tup:

You do realize the entire point that I am releasing these on forums before putting them on the website is because I want to polish it up, right? I am looking for criticism, not snark, fart-face!

He was helping you.... :unsure:

True, but with an added sass, which I responded to my referring to him as a fart-face. :yes:

The :tup: face is not sass. :tup:
I didn't mean it seriously. Hence why I called him a fart-face and not something more wholesome. The sass was him saying I needed to use spell-check, which was I took as very sassy. (In a sexy sort-of way.)

(Although, Fun-Fact: When I first rewrote it, it was on a forum called Legendfire that doesn't allow spell-check.)

Fair enough.. Maybe he was trying to be sassy, I don't know :lol:
 
Here's an interesting thought, I posted this short-story on a website called Legend Fire, a website dedicated to literature, and I posted it a day before I posted it on here. They stress that if you are to post a short-story, you should critique one as well.

It's only fair.

Anyway, not one person has critiqued the short-story, and yet, here on Off Topix, a general-discussion forum, there has actually been some critique.

Bizarre.
 
Maybe they thought pointing out the obvious was too easy. There's more than just spelling mistakes in there, by the way.

Now for the somewhat harder part.
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
But, of course, she didn't know that I was watching. That put a strain on our relationship because I knew more about her then even she knew about herself
I don't quite like the flow here. Maybe lose the "but" and replace the "that".
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
curved like a baseball
Is this a thing?
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
She didn't see the kindness of her smile because she was never smiling, not when she looked into that damn mirror!
I'd prefer "because she never smiled", though I couldn't tell you why.
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
She saw the sparkle in her eyes, but only when at the brink of tears.
I think it might be more poetic without the "but".
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
When she looked in the mirror [...] told her that she was skinny.
Maybe cut down on the "and"s.
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
She saw something that everybody else was entirely oblivious to; she saw something was so ugly and flawed.
"She saw something no one else did; she saw something ugly and flawed." :dontknow:
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
I watched as she broke the mirror, and then a shard meet her wrist.
"[...] mirror; put a shard to her wrist." sounds better to me.


Bah, I always feel like I'm being so negative.
 
Evil Eye said:
Maybe they thought pointing out the obvious was too easy. There's more than just spelling mistakes in there, by the way.

Bah, I always feel like I'm being so negative.

You're not too negative, just sassy and filled with insults. Bah gawd, man, would it kill you to try and not insult my work, it'd be different if it was a criticism, but it isn't. If you would have just put your opinion without that little blurb, it'd be fine, but there, you might say you meant something different but I believe you're just being rude. It'd be fine if it was a regular thread, but this is something I put a lot of my heart into. I think showing a little respect is in order.

I appreciate it, though. However, most of those aren't actually mistakes. In-fact, none of them are, but personal preferences, and some of them I agree on. Thanks.
 
I can honestly say I don't do it on purpose. It comes quite naturally and I don't see it. So, for what it's worth, I'm sorry.
That sentence you highlighted was meant to be self depreciating.
Nicholas McConnaughay said:
However, most of those aren't actually mistakes.
Purposefully so, hence my second sentence.
 
I thought it was brilliantly written. Very unique to write a short story through the eyes of a squirrel. The story was a sad one and I could feel what she thought and was going through. The punch line ending pulled it all together for me.
 
Back
Top Bottom