A US soldier in Afghanistan has shot dead 10 civilians and wounded five in Kandahar province after suffering a nervous breakdown, US and local officials say.
View the full article
View the full article
Off Topix: Embrace the Unexpected in Every Discussion
Off Topix is a well established general discussion forum that originally opened to the public way back in 2009! We provide a laid back atmosphere and our members are down to earth. We have a ton of content and fresh stuff is constantly being added. We cover all sorts of topics, so there's bound to be something inside to pique your interest. We welcome anyone and everyone to register & become a member of our awesome community.
'Rogue' US soldier kills Afghans
- Thread starter Headliner
- Start date
Why is the word rogue in quotes in the headline?
Is the robot poster, or its human masters implying that the US High Command, and by extension, the American People, condone this sort of behavior?
Is the robot poster, or its human masters implying that the US High Command, and by extension, the American People, condone this sort of behavior?
Exactly. But when they refer to the armed forces as heroes they don't use quotes. I agree to a certain degree, but they are far from heroes. Some of them do awful things (Like this guy, killing 16 innocent civilians). Some of them act more like bullies than anything else. Just like cops and other authority figures, some of them are rogue and crooked. It's a jingoistic attitude to condone everything they do.
And it is assinine to condem them across the board like some others do.
FOR THE MOST PART, they are heroes.
And yes, as with cops, and teachers, and whatever else you wish to name, there are a few assholes who are the exception.
But, by and large, the majority are the heroes they are made out to be by those of use who when they see a member of the military in uniform, thank them for their service to our country.
No, I don't ask them first to make sure they didn't kill any civilians, or were part of a unit that may have committed a war crime, or anything else. I thank them for their putting their life on the line, even if they have never seen a minute of combat, to ensure that we have the freedom to get online and call the US Military 'baby killers' and to burn the flag.
FOR THE MOST PART, they are heroes.
And yes, as with cops, and teachers, and whatever else you wish to name, there are a few assholes who are the exception.
But, by and large, the majority are the heroes they are made out to be by those of use who when they see a member of the military in uniform, thank them for their service to our country.
No, I don't ask them first to make sure they didn't kill any civilians, or were part of a unit that may have committed a war crime, or anything else. I thank them for their putting their life on the line, even if they have never seen a minute of combat, to ensure that we have the freedom to get online and call the US Military 'baby killers' and to burn the flag.
I don't mean to be offensive to soldiers or anyone who has served. But here is my own personal opinion.
The word hero should not be something thrown so generally. It depends on the person and their actions not profession. Anyone can be heroic through their own ways: a teacher can be a hero, a parent, a cop, a soldier but not all of them are. That's a problem news corps admittedly have. Labeling a whole group instead of the individual because it's easier that way. They generalize to the point of labeling every cop or soldier as heroic. In this case it's just one bad apple which spoiled the bunch.
The word hero should not be something thrown so generally. It depends on the person and their actions not profession. Anyone can be heroic through their own ways: a teacher can be a hero, a parent, a cop, a soldier but not all of them are. That's a problem news corps admittedly have. Labeling a whole group instead of the individual because it's easier that way. They generalize to the point of labeling every cop or soldier as heroic. In this case it's just one bad apple which spoiled the bunch.
Similar threads
