What's New
Off Topix: Embrace the Unexpected in Every Discussion

Off Topix is a well established general discussion forum that originally opened to the public way back in 2009! We provide a laid back atmosphere and our members are down to earth. We have a ton of content and fresh stuff is constantly being added. We cover all sorts of topics, so there's bound to be something inside to pique your interest. We welcome anyone and everyone to register & become a member of our awesome community.

Proof Bin Laden Is Dead

Corleone

Platinum Member
Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2009
Posts
7,265
OT Bucks
15,868
Should proof be given? Yes or no. Please explain why you feel one way or the other.
 
Yes.



Right now all we have to go on is what they are telling us. For all we know, they could have him alive some where and are torturing him right now.. Pumping him for information and whatnot.



I want to believe they killed him and I think they did but proof would be great & it would put all the conspiracy theories to rest.
 
Exactly. I believe Osama Bin Laden is dead, but as you've said, proof would be extra confirmation and it would stop conspiracy theorists. Saddam Hussein's death was publicized; therefore, I don't see how Osama Bin Laden is any different.
 
Proof won't change anything. You give them a photo and they say it was photoshopped. You give them a video recording of the dead body and they say it was staged with actors.



Those dead set on not believing he's dead will continue to do so as the only people who will accept the proof is fact are those who already believe they killed him.



Still, it would be nice to have a photo at least for all those who don't necessarily believe it but are open to any proof provided by the government that he was in fact killed.
 
Nebulous said:
Yes.



Right now all we have to go on is what they are telling us. For all we know, they could have him alive some where and are torturing him right now.. Pumping him for information and whatnot.



I want to believe they killed him and I think they did but proof would be great & it would put all the conspiracy theories to rest.



I'm not saying I believe this, but what you just said about him being tortured just blew my mind. Thought you should know... Lmao



I think he's dead they just shot him so many times that the body was too gruesome to show to the public.
 
Well obama said he wont release the photos... Even if they did, what BZ said will probably happen. People still wont believe it. I dont know how they could go about actually PROVING they killed him without the doubters doubting it.
tongue.gif
 
Osama Bin Laden's wife said that they killed her husband. What more proof do you need? lol I personally don't need proof but I really don't see the problem with giving the public a photo either. I'm on the fence about this, because I don't need proof, but to all the nonbelievers I wouldn't mind them getting their own confirmation.
 
It's pretty much a do you trust your government? type situation.
 
Jughead said:
Osama Bin Laden's wife said that they killed her husband. What more proof do you need? lol I personally don't need proof but I really don't see the problem with giving the public a photo either. I'm on the fence about this, because I don't need proof, but to all the nonbelievers I wouldn't mind them getting their own confirmation.

They won't believe it anyway. They'll just say that the photo's been photo-shopped :\
 
Oh, but then they do this:





MIKE MALLOY: I have heard some commentators talk about the fact that, all the lives that have been lost in this war on terror, and now the summary execution of the person responsible. But as soon as I heard that, I thought, well, bin Laden really didn't have anything to do -- did he? -- with Iraq. And I think his only relationship with Afghanistan was geographical.



But Iraq -- all the death in Iraq was not caused by bin Laden. The death in Iraq was caused by George W. Bush. Five thousand Americans, tens of thousands permanently damaged and shot to pieces, a million Iraqis dead -- that wasn't bin Laden. That was George Bush. So when does Seal Unit 6, or whatever it's called, drop in on George Bush? Bush was responsible for a lot more death, innocent death, than bin Laden. Wasn't he, or am I wrong here?



http://newsbusters.org/blogs/tim-gr...alloy-when-will-navy-seals-take-out-death-dea



http://www.mikemalloy.com/
 
George Bush didn't crash planes into the trade centers. Al qaeda did. And if you want my honest opinion on Pakistan, I truly believe that they hid Osama Bin Laden indirectly by not taking the measures needed to find him. War is war. I deeply feel for the families that lost lives due to crossfire, but it's war. War is in no way pretty. There has never been a war where innocent people haven't died. It's horrible, but it's part of it. I believe if Pakistan would of worked more closely with the US openly and honestly, it wouldn't be that high of a number of causalities.
 
No, graphic proof need not be disclosed.



As for Doc's link, George W. Bush does have a lot to answer for if he ever does end up before his God.
 
Do we really need proof?



Barack Obama wouldn't tell the whole world that Osama bin Laden is dead unless he was 100% percent sure of that being the truth. It's not the kind of thing you can afford to get wrong. I don't think it really makes a difference, because Al-Qaeda will operate regardless and there is the threat of a revenge attack.
 
No.. who do they need to prove it to? The public? And Why? Because we think that we have the right or need to know everything…

If he is dead he is dead, if he is alive and being tortured then so be it.. who cares.

I think what they did is brilliant, dump his body at sea to be fish food.. never to be found.. nowhere to turn into a temple or another Mecca.. just gone forever.
 
Yes, I personally don't care one way or another, however, there is numerous that had their families killed among numerous other things deprived from them and for reasons of entirely garnering closure, seeing Bin's body feels justifiable, after all, they had no problem showing people jumping out of the towers to their death hoping that somehow they'd survive whilst they were crumbling to the ground.
 
There would still be people on both sides that claim it was a hoax and that he was either alive and free and plotting away, or had already been dead for a long time, or he had never done anything to anybody and was a scapegoat, or that he was a clone from the mothership, or whatever.
 
Back
Top Bottom